EYE OF HORUS - The independent DOCTOR WHO resource - link to front page
Link to EYE OF HORUS HOME Link to DOCTOR WHO NEW SERIES 7 Link to DOCTOR WHO CLASSIC SERIES Link to DOCTOR WHO NEWS Link to EXCLUSIVE COMPETITIONS + EDITORIAL FEATURES Link to REVIEWS - DVD + AUDIO + PRINT Link to AMAZON.CO.UK - DOCTOR WHO official store Link to SEARCH within eyeofhorus.org.uk
   
MERCHANDISE REVIEWS
Choose DVD
Choose AUDIO (Audiobooks and Music)
Choose BOOKS (Fiction and Non-Fiction)
Choose DOCTOR WHO LIVE EVENTS
Choose DOCTOR WHO MAGAZINE
Choose CLASSIC SERIES TOYS
Choose FORBIDDEN PLANET EXCLUSIVE TOYS
     
AUDIOBOOK and SERIES OST REVIEWS  
Choose a DOCTOR WHO UNABRIDGED review
Choose a DOCTOR WHO ABRIDGED review

Choose a DESTINY OF THE DOCTOR review
Choose a SERPENT CREST (2011) review
Choose a DEMON QUEST (2010) review
Choose a HORNETS' NEST (2009) review
Choose a SARAH JANE ADVENTURES review
Choose a BLAKE'S 7 review
Choose a TORCHWOOD review
Choose a SOUNDTRACK & DOCUMENTARY review

         

DOCTOR WHO | DEMON QUEST VOLUME 4: STARFALL

 
"...the most enjoyable, most polished
and engaging episode with a jaw-dropping ending...

PLOTLINE

Two things arrive on the same night in Central Park, New York, 1976. The first is a fireball from space, bringing with it a new identity for one Alice Trefusis. The second is the Tardis, carrying the Doctor and his friends on the trail of an unusual comic book cover. The Doctor's strength is sapped by something in the New York air - but what could cause such a malaise? As he and Mike are first mixed up with the police and then taken on an aerial ride over the city, Mrs Wibbsey comes face to face with the legendary Talkies film star Mimsy Loyne. And all the while, long multicoloured scarves and floppy felt hats are climbing the stairs of the Dakota Building...

Performed by Tom Baker and cast.

COMMENT

It's all been a bit, well, "samey" up to now.

Paul Magrs' DOCTOR WHO - DEMON QUEST has not lived up to the enthralling, yes, enthralling first batch of audio stories under the HORNETS' NEST banner.

However, fresh from listening to its fourth episode, STARFALL, the DEMON QUEST is truly galloping across the endless expanse of space and the turbulent vortex of time.

In BBC AUDIO's exclusive audio adventure, with CLASSIC SERIES incarnation of the Doctor played garrulously by Tom Baker supported by Richard Franklin as Mike Yates and Susan Jameson as Mrs. Wibbsey, may have it its zenith as the action delivers itself to New York (USA) on 12 July 1972.

The USP ("unique selling point") for this episode is that the narration is provided from the viewpoint of Buddy Hudson, a budding (sorry.) writer and aficionado of the 1930s American "Penny dreadful". It's a refreshing approach and executed superbly with reverence to that period without being nauseous, and it is complimented by a suitably laconic music track and sound effects that transport you to the oppressive and arid streets of summer in the city. The narration format echoes the equally effective episode of QUANTUM LEAP (PLAY IT AGAIN, SEYMOUR) as it parodied a Humphrey Bogart film noir set in the 1950s.

Partially fixed (a missing "special geometer" retrieved), the TARDIS breaks free from the "only time travel" constraint and deposits its occupants in Central Park as it marvels at its own out-of-this-world deliverance - a meteor crash. A scene that is depicted on the cover of the comic book in the Doctor's possession since the village fete's "bring and buy" sale.

With the meteor imbibing Buddy Hudson's girlfriend (Alice Trefusis, and personal assistant to one-time film star, Mimsy Loyne) with alien powers (akin to those of SUPERMAN), the Doctor, with his own life-force being affected by an unknown influence, discovers that today, 12 July 1972, there are no coincidences, especially when he discovers that within the meteor is. well, spoilers.

Doctor (to Mike Yates): It may have slipped your notice, Mr Yates, that I'm not Superman.

Initially, you think that the subplot revolving around the relationship between the human-alien hybrid Alice (now calling herself "Ms Starfall"), her employer (Mimsy) and her boyfriend is purely padding as it generally deviates from the "demon quest" itself, however, skilfully Magrs, like a witty little knitter, secures the loose thread of coincidence and delivers a climax that will - yes, I guarantee it - have you on AMAZON.CO.UK buying the final episode (SEPULCHRE) quicker than you can say "knit one, purl one".

"Villain": My chickens come home to roost.

With Tom Baker absent from the majority of the episode, you think that you'll be short-changed but no as he is there with words of wisdom and doused with his (character's) penchant for mild and seemingly innocent innuendo;

Doctor (to Ms Starfall): Ready when you are, Ms Starfall!

As for his inference that he (in another incarnation) and the odious faded film actress, Loyne, had had a "dance" in 1922 is devilishly fruity if not frivolous.

To date, DOCTOR WHO - DEMONS QUEST - STARFALL is the most enjoyable, superbly polished (in terms of production values) and engaging episode, and with that jaw-dropping cliffhanger the series seems to be heading to finish on an unequivocal high.

I hope so.

The next episode: DEMON QUEST: SEPULCHRE.

BUY DISCS OR DOWNLOAD DIRECT FROM AUDIOGO

 

EOH CONTRIBUTOR

MATTHEW WALTER

EOH RATING

eyeofhorus audio rating: 9/10

INFORMATION

DOCTOR WHO - TOM BAKER is the Doctor

Released 02.12.2010
RRP: £9.99

Duration: 70 minutes

 

Online visitor hits since 13 April 2003

© www.eyeofhorus.org.uk 2015
(Extra © information visit here)

"DOCTOR WHO commentary since 1983"

Email us EDITORIAL EMAIL - We do not reply to emails

Follow us on TWITTER - eyeofhorus.org.uk on Twitter


Contact us - EDITORIAL EMAIL
Link back to HOME - EYE OF HORUS Link to DOCTOR WHO NEW SERIES 2 Link to CLASSIC SERIES 1963-96 Link to CURRENT NEWS Link to BIG FINISH AUDIO Link to EYE OF HORUS - EDITORIAL + GIVEAWAYS Link to DOCTOR WHO MERCHANDISE EMAIL - EOH cannot reply to all emails due to time restrictions